Editors PickOpinion

One of the Last Chapels Left in our Community is Under Threat.

By Noah Ralphs

In many ways, our communities have been increasingly rejuvenated since Covid. Running, coffee, Pilates, the environment and social clubs have meant that our once atomistic societies have rebounded into the well-rounded open communities we all knew they could be. Football has often stood alone as one of the last bulwarks of communities. A place where we congregate in awe – but mostly despair – watching the greatest talents of our generation play in such an unsatisfactory manner that it causes mass emotion of pure rage and apathy.

I have been walking down from Seven Sisters tube station down Tottenham High Road to White Hart Lane since I was 4. It was the community that my family and I always belonged. The terraces were pews in which fans from across London and the Home Counties met and bonded. I get emotional just thinking about the years I spent on the terraces now.

Football has always come under threat. The tradition of the game – working-class, a universal language and pure beauty has always remained at its core despite its masqueraded outlook as a commercial game installed for the rich. Football may be the most profitable consumer product of all time; people across the world fall in love with the game from the moment they are born. It’s not complicated; all is needed is 4 jumpers and a ball and you can play a game in any: Favela, street, estate or back garden across the world. While many have exploited the game for its profitability, backlash has always restrained the core values from being destroyed. It’s the universal game.

Despite this, there is far more we could do as communities and societies to protect the beautiful game here at home.

Andy Burnham and Sir Keir Starmer, while being two very different Prime Ministers, both share a love of Everton and the second biggest team from North London, respectively. The Football Governance Bill was commendable in creating an independent regulator to monitor the affairs of Football. The Bill, in my opinion, didn’t go further in trying to tackle the main issue in football today: the increased hyper-consumerism of the sport by outside influences.

It is time that clubs are mandated to adopt the 50+1 rule. Football should be governed by the terraces, not by the boardroom. Fans across the world deserve to take ownership of their clubs. It would be like allowing a state to be run by an oligarchy, not a democracy. Why should football clubs be no different?

Furthermore, in the face of increased corporate greed and cheating, fans have increasingly realised an evident truth about football clubs.

Football clubs don’t live in an anomie to the cities they are in but are the representation of their suburb, town or city as a whole. While I am no fan of Man City and its board’s shocking misappropriation, I have to commend the reaction of its fan base in the wake of such shocking allegations. Allegations in which it had little to no part. It embraced its identity. An identity based on Britpop, Manchester and Oasis. Not its hyper-consumerised modern image but an image based on the history and culture it represents.

When was the last time you heard Liverpool singing songs from the Beatles like in the 60s or Tottenham playing Chas and Dave before the game? Hyper-consumerism has meant that more nuanced and, in particular, working-class aspects of the game are dissipating from our game. 50+1 could change that. If fans gain control of the narrative, they control the identity.

Obviously, our histories and narratives aren’t always commendable. There are ugly, if not repulsive, aspects of some of our teams and cultures that transpire in horrific and terrible ways. As a kid, I shouldn’t have had to turn to my dad in bewilderment about why Chelsea FC kept on making a terrible hissing noise towards the Tottenham crowd. It’s a balance, but a balance that football fans should be credited with making and called out when falling short.

Football is to many the community. The empowerment of fans would constitute the revival of the sacred bond between club and community. A bond that hasn’t disappeared but is always under threat. It’s the right of every fan to stand up and shout ‘Gertcha’ in the face of this attack, and it’s time the government acts.

The Gown Queen's University Belfast

The Gown has provided respected, quality and independent student journalism from Queen's University, Belfast since its 1955 foundation, by Dr. Richard Herman. Having had an illustrious line of journalists and writers for almost 70 years, that proud history is extremely important to us. The Gown is consistent in its quest to seek and develop the talents of aspiring student writers.

Leave a Reply