Hellish Homicide: The Genesis of Christa Pike
By Órla Moran

Warning: This article contains details that readers may find distressing.
Christa Pike is the only woman in Tennessee on death row and would have been the first woman to be executed in the state in over 200 years. [1] Here’s everything you need to know about Christa Pike and the gruesome murder of 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer.
Whilst everyone is discussing the botched execution that recently made headlines, I want to instead focus on the beginning of this gory tale. Christa Pike was born on the 10th of March 1976. Christa didn’t by any means have an easy childhood. She began to be raped by her grandmother’s boyfriend (Ernest Johnson) as early as the age of two years old. Johnson kept Pike quiet by threatening to kill her pets, or to lock her away. Indications of this abuse surfaced at school, when Pike drew a picture of a ‘huge penis and a demon face’ when asked to draw something she did at home. At age nine, the continuous sexual assault and growing up in a broken home began to take its toll. Pike started drinking, smoking weed and self-harming. At age eleven, Pike was raped by her 37-year-old neighbour, and subsequently attempted suicide when she was twelve. On top of this, she was raped again at age 17. [2] Many professionals have advocated for Pike, such as psychiatric expert Dr. Brand, who stated that Pike had ‘experienced more severe trauma than 99 per cent of the US population.’ [2]
While these factors must be considered, the severity of the murder Pike carried out cannot be ignored. On the 12th of January 1995, Pike ‘just felt mean that day’ [3] and was enraged with jealousy that classmate Colleen Slemmer was ‘secretly dating her devil-worshipping boyfriend’ (Tadaryl Shipp). [2] Pike, Shipp, and her friend Shadolla Peterson lured Colleen into a forest where they brutally tortured and murdered her. Slemmer begged for her life but was told to be quiet because ‘it was harder to hurt somebody when they were talking to you.’ [2] Pike ‘cut Slemmer’s throat as she begged for mercy’. [4] The actual murder weapon was a rock, which Pike used to bludgeon Slemmer’s skull. [4] Slemmer’s body was mistaken for an animal’s body, unrecognisable as a human, being nude from the top half of her body, and a pentagram carved into her chest. [4]
After watching a documentary based on Pike’s killing of Slemmer – Mean Girl Murders, friends of Pike discussed the aftermath of the event. One friend said that Pike returned to their room after the murder and told her everything in an extremely excited and animalistic manner, and that Pike showed them a piece of Slemmer’s skull that she took as a souvenir. They also mentioned that Pike said, ‘Don’t tell anyone or I’ll kill you too.’ [5]
Reem Aslem, a UN expert on violence against women and girls, says that Pike “was unable to emotionally regulate” and was “suffering from severe trauma, neurological disabilities and bipolar disorder”, at the time of the murder. [2] A variety of experts believe that after Pike’s traumatic childhood, her solitary confinement for over 30 years, and her evidence of remorse from her former cellmate Graves – “Christa is a beautiful soul who did a really bad thing when she was very young. She is not that person anymore” – that she should not be executed and has suffered enough. [5]
Even Beth Bergman, one of Pike’s attorneys, said, “What I do not understand is how our collective reaction to that pain is to create more pain and harm”, regarding Pike being on death row. [6] Furthermore, Nashville Scene argues that “People can come to understand the weight that they’ve caused. They can change profoundly while still being held accountable.” [7]
However, the most crucial opinions in this matter are, of course, from Colleen Slemmer’s family. They have spent more than 30 years seeking justice for Colleen. Slemmer’s mother, May Martinez, says at the end of the documentary (Mean Girl Murders) that ‘once Pike has been executed, then she can start living her life again’. [5]
Bibliography:
[1] “Christa Pike Breaks Silence & Says ‘There’s Pain in My Mind and My Soul’ After Returning to Jail from Botched Execution.” The Sun (UK). https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/40859473/christa-pike-first-statement-botched-execution/.
[2] “The ‘Satanic’ Teen Killer Who Carved Pentagram onto Love Rival & Kept Piece of Skull… with Chilling Final Execution Plea.” The Sun (US). https://www.the-sun.com/news/17060435/murderer-beat-classmate-death-executed/.
[3] ABC News (Australia). “Christa Pike, Colleen Slemmer Survives Execution Attempt.” October 2, 2026. https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-10-02/christa-pike-colleen-slemmer-survives-execution-attempt/107211372.
[4] “What Did Christa Pike Do? A Look Back at Her 1995 Crime.” USA Today, October 1, 2026. https://eu.usatoday.com/story/news/crime/2026/10/01/what-christa-pike-do-executed-murder/92035330007/.
[5] Mean Girl Murders. Season 2, episode 1, “She-Devil.” IMDb. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt32200697/.
[6] NewsChannel 5 Nashville. “Tennessee Prepares to Execute Christa Pike for the Murder of Colleen Slemmer.” WTVF. https://www.newschannel5.com/news/tennessee-prepares-to-execute-christa-pike-for-the-murder-of-colleen-slemmer.
[7] Nashville Scene. “Christa Pike Death Row Execution Advocates.” https://www.nashvillescene.com/news/pithinthewind/christa-pike-death-row-execution-advocates/article_51d9ba89-f5de-42fe-b53b-9ce198901b21.html.
