Behind the Gilded Cage: Male Mental Health and The “Loneliness Epidemic”
By Sean Colligan

The approach of International Men’s Day this Thursday has again brought the oft-mentioned issue of male mental health back into the spotlight. While there is undeniably a trend of poor mental wellbeing among men and boys—especially in the North where you’re 25% more likely to have a mental disorder than in mainland Britain [1]—are suggestions of a solely male “loneliness epidemic” not excluding the women and girls who suffer from the exact same decline of third spaces, waning of community bonds and outright alienation exacerbated by the Covid-19 pandemic? Is the loneliness that has propelled at-risk teens into the fringes of inceldom and subsequent toxic manosphere not a byproduct of the patriarchal structures that exist to disempower half the population? If men are indeed trapped, is it not in a prison of their own making? Their very own gilded cage?
It is very easy to scoff at suggestions of uniquely male suffering, what with Northern Ireland having higher rates of femicide than “not just other parts of the United Kingdom but quite a lot of the world” [2], in the words of then Safeguarding Minister Jess Phillips. While a lot of the rhetoric around Men’s Day is positive and certainly moving in the right direction, that it is okay to talk about your feelings, awareness of things like prostate cancer that I have written about before, the whole thing seems to gloss over a lot of the systemic issues. International Men’s Day has its place, and is on balance a good initiative, but there also must be action taken on the more unsavoury and frightening aspects of masculinity. I find a lot of the self-soothing, self-congratulatory rhetoric a bit twee when you read about the Cornell 7 and how, in a group chat of fifty-seven people, the other fifty said nothing about the alleged assault. It is easy to see how women, 98% of whom in Northern Ireland have experienced one form of abuse or violence in their lifetime [3], rightfully view the whole thing with scepticism.
Yes, men do suffer, but a lot of that suffering is self-imposed. Not on an individual level, of course, but the groupthink of gender norms discourages vulnerability and true connection. Women do tend to enjoy closer and more enriching friendships with each other than their male counterparts. The inability of men to express any sort of negative emotion that isn’t anger or irritability, lest they be viewed as weak or incompetent, is a social contract that none of us signed up for, yet it is up to us men to finally annul it for good. While those who lament the loneliness of men only are right in saying there is a problem, they are ignoring the fact that it is a universal one, and in their diagnosis wrongly place the burden of remedy. It is not up to women to fix their emptiness in romantic affection, which many view as the ultimate cure and so feel entitled to it, but for men to drop these silly and outdated restrictions and leave them in the past.
International Men’s Day and other such programmes are getting the second step of that right, and rightly encouraging men to open up, but we men as a whole are missing the crucial preamble: it is not up to women to fix our problems. The bonds of friendship and community, male or female, are a lot more important for health and wellbeing than the very transient nature of romantic relationships—especially in today’s climate of situationships and people being “so in like with each other”—and women should not have to suffer and face violence as a result of men feeling that they are owed something. While there is still a lot of work to be done around issues like the gender pay gap, it is fair to say that society as a whole has come a long way from the days of women being treated as legal property. The sinister power complex that has remained as a primordial undercurrent in society is still yet to be seriously challenged, and no matter how many Obsessions, Adolesences or Inside the Manospheres are made, the problem still remains. While these works always inspire a brief but constructive discussion around gender issues, the keyword is brief, and always without the self-examination that I think is required by all men before we can finally see serious progress. We could free ourselves from this cage of suffering if we really wanted to, but are we too attached to the gold bars?
References
[1] O’Neill, Siobhan. Rooney, Nicola. “Mental health in Northern Ireland: an urgent situation”. The Lancet. 19th December 2018. https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanpsy/article/PIIS2215-0366(18)30392-4/fulltext
[2] Hughes, Brendan. “NI femicide rates are higher than ‘quite a lot of the world’”. BBC News NI. 18th March 2026. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c4g2gwpk371o
[3] “Extent of violence experienced by women and girls revealed in new reports”. The Executive Office. 7th September 2023. https://www.executiveoffice-ni.gov.uk/news/extent-violence-experienced-women-and-girls-revealed-new-reports
